Musings of a serial startup sales executive

My last post inspired some very insightful commentary, including one comment from a very seasoned IT sales executive about the importance of getting incentive compensation, spiffs and rewards right. He highlighted his success with the implementation of a President’s Club, a scheme that enabled the top ten percent of his sales force to go on a weeklong retreat to an exotic locale once a year.  I am a huge proponent of these kind of programs. They not only foster healthy competition and team cohesion but they also bind your very best people to the organization by creating wonderful, memorable experiences.

Unfortunately, President’s club (or ‘Club’ as it’s often called) is usually not an appropriate incentive at an startup. The reasons for this are as follows:

  • Lack of Product Market Fit: Most startups I have worked at initiate early sales efforts in an attempt to validate their proposition or establish a beachhead sector and ideal entry point for their offering. Many of their earliest customers got advantageous terms in exchange for acting as references or informing the onward development of the product. It would be strange to fly the team to the Caribbean as a reward for writing loss-leader business.
  • No repeatable sales model: The first year of selling at a B2B startup is generally a time of experimentation. High touch? Low touch? Inside? Outside? Direct?  Channel? Until these questions are answered decisively, there’s simply no point putting a gigantic year end spiff on the table. You want to avoid setting your renaissance reps up for failure.
  • Cash is King: Whatever the folks at Tech Crunch say, this ain’t the dot com era. The days of junkets, nightclubbing and lavish employee perks are a thing of the past  (at least they are for B2B startups). It might be prudent to do whatever you can to conserve capital. Save Club for when you’re cash flow positive.
So how should startup businesses look to reward their best sales reps? Intrinsically, of course! Remember, your first salespeople should be renaissance reps. This usually  means that they are juniors or rookies with a hunger to take the next step professionally. The best reward they can possibly get is training, experience and knowledge. If you manage them in a hands-on fashion they’ll get all three in spades. If you also take care to stress that you are working together to build something special and reinforce this sentiment by explaining and celebrating the significance of each one of your early wins, you’ll be providing your people with intrinsic rewards that they will cherish (and leverage) for the rest of their professional lives. Remember, professional development is a powerful reward, one that your ideal rep craves.
This is not to diminish the importance of extrinsic rewards, far from it! Your sales reps should be taking ten to fifteen points off of every sale. They should enjoy at least one awesome team building outing a quarter, a day at the races or climbing lessons, say. I know of one French startup that opens a bottle of Champagne every time they close a deal (Vive la France!). Take ‘em out and buy them steaks! But President’s club? Save it for when you’re all grown up!

OK, so you’ve developed your first reference clients and your inbound marketing program is starting to bare fruit in the form of inbound inquiries, many of which are successfully converted by your telemarketing team into BANT qualified leads. You’ve retained your first ‘Renaissance’ sales rep to mop up this newfound capacity, an articulate college graduate with two years of dialing for dollars in a fixed-line telephony business under his belt. You know he’s hungry for professional advancement and money. He’s raw but he’s smart. How will you get him ramped and productive?

You could do what many large established businesses do and plug him into a sales methodology like Solution Selling, SPIN or Miler Heiman. Before you do remember that such players are full of ‘Coin-Operated’ sales representatives, journeymen who you cannot afford to have on your team. Remember also that your competitors will leverage the same tactics to ramp their reps. It may be a radical assertion, but I would avoid formal sales training for awhile in favor of what I think of as the true key to startup sales success: preparation. Sounds vague, right? Not very descriptive. Allow me to elaborate.

When I discuss preparation in the context of training and ramping a sales rep, I mean inculcating him with a set of behaviors that will not only improve his chances of lifelong professional success but also ensure that your customers are delighted from the first touch, that their buying experience is wonderful enough to give them a warm feeling every time they think of your brand. It is also the key to building a high performance sales culture.

Preparation doesn’t come out of text book or a canned sales training course. It is a disciplined approach to understanding customers and their needs. It’s also what the world’s best athletes do routinely. Like a baseball pitcher reviewing hours of tape to prepare to face hitters, a distance runner training at altitude or a tennis player hitting thousands of ground strokes a day, so your reps must also prepare. It’s grueling, it’s hard. It’s what winners do.

So how do sales reps prepare? Here are some key activities that all salespeople must undertake daily if they are to be the very best:

Comprehensively understand the customer’s working environment and priorities: My customers are mostly senior IT decision makers. In order to prepare myself to sell to them I read books on Enterprise Application Integration, Network Administration, Computer Science and Cloud Computing. I also read all of the key IT blogs and publications. I know I have to speak in their vernacular if I am to gain their trust. I also know that I have to have a strong grasp of how their strategy is evolving. Is IT outsourcing topical? I have to be able to speak to it. Are they migrating their systems to the cloud? If so, it’s my job  to deeply understand the challenges inherent in such a transition.

Solution selling (by which I mean the socratic process of unearthing a need and selling to it) is not possible in the absence of trust. If your reps do not have a clear understanding of what their customers do and what their challenges are, then they will be lumped in with the other  ”salesmen” – a term that is synonymous with “scammer’ in the mind of many buyers.

So, how can you develop this kind of understanding and sensitivity in your reps? MAKE THEM READ! MAKE THEM CRAM! If they’re not reading a book a week for the first two months, then make it an MBO and bonus them on success in this area. Once they have begun to familiarize themselves with the landscape, engage them in debate and discussion every day. Make them present. Role play. Include them in strategic meetings. Brainstorm which questions they can ask their prospects to get to the heart of their requirement. After a quarter or so they will be ready have truly consultative discourse with prospects.

Caution: Make sure that, once ramped, your reps stay fresh by keeping up to date with key events and shifts in your target market. Assess their comprehension continuously. Take steps to discourage complacency.

Review Tape: Got an inside team? Record their discussions with customers and prospects. Are your reps out in the field? Equip them with LiveScribe pens  and make uploading the resulting wav files into the CRM a bonus-able activity. Sitting down with your reps, one-on-one, once a week and reviewing these recordings will be a wonderful learning experience for all. It will not only keep you, the sales manager, close to the customers and their ever changing needs, but it will also make your reps understand that pitching is an iterative activity, requiring constant innovation and improvement. The advice you give them in the context of such a review will carry real weight. The praise and encouragement you give them will be much more meaningful.

It is of vital importance to note that this is not a simple training exercise. Sales pros and rookies alike require this kind of  review. It is is a critical component in measuring the effectiveness of your team. It also removes speculation and keeps everyone marching in lockstep.

Blog, tweet and post: Building a personal brand is a critical prospecting activity. Get your reps listening to their target audience on forums and in communities. Familiarize them with engagement techniques and get them posting. Ask them to write a short industry focused blog (no more then 250 words a week). Get them tweeting the company blog posts, webinars , whitepaper releases and relevant articles and postings that they find through their own research. This activity will align them with the marketing team and mature their thinking about their market and their prospects’ challenges. Make this a bonused activity and work with them to measure results and refine content.

Caution: Ensure that all rep produced content is both explicitly personal (i.e not produced under the corporate brand) and subject to editorial oversight.

What is the result of implementing the above strategies? Ideally, you’ll end up with sales representative who, by virtue of their understanding and sympathy for their customers’ challenges, can provide meaningful solutions and, in doing so, create remarkable experiences for customers. You’ll also avoid complacency through keeping the dialogue fresh and religiously reviewing tape. Get them ramped  and then implement your sales methodology. They’ll get more out of it. Believe me.

The rewards of this approach are manifold: One of my sales reps once showed me an email in which his customer remarked that ‘everyone at your organization is clearly very smart’. Bingo.

Hiring sales people at a startup business can be a challenge. In my last blog post I delineated  five ways that startups can de-risk the sales hiring process. I have since read this rather excellent article entitled “The Sales Learning Curve” by Mark Leslie and Charles Holloway over at the Harvard Business Review. Messrs. Leslie and Holloway also focus on best practice in this area. They breakdown sales candidates into three profiles: “Renaissance” Reps, “Enlightened Reps” and “Coin-Operated” Reps. Each profile aligns with where a businesses is in it’s learning curve.

Renaissance Reps: are uber-eagles. They are integral to the customer development process and ideal for early (seed) stage businesses. They are not only adept at gathering requirements but they also aggressively learn what they need to know to articulate the proposition. They even create their own collateral, if necessary. Renaissance reps make sales but  they also help the business to learn what the ideal sales model, product positioning and entry points are. They establish product market fit. If your business needs to pivot these guys will be amongst the first to know.

Enlightened Reps: are Eagles. You would look to hire to this profile when you have gained notable traction in you target market and are getting closer to a repeatable sales model. Such salespeople need more training and resourcing than Renaissance reps do, but are still very driven and self sufficient. They do not mind operating in the absence of a proven sales and marketing model and will happily do whatever is necessary to generate leads, be it coldcalling or networking.

Coin Operated Reps: are journeymen. When you find yourself hiring to this profile it’s time to break out the bubbly. You’ve arrived! You have a repeatable sales and marketing model. In fact, you’re generating so many leads that sales is now merely a fulfillment exercise. While this class of rep must be experienced and presentable, it is no longer critical that they possess the intellectual horsepower or self reliance of the Enlightened or Renaissance profile. Con-ops need a lot of resources and require substantial monitoring, so make sure that you are churning out leads and are have documented sales processes in place before hiring any.

It should now be pretty clear which type of rep you need to focus on hiring. There is one last profile to consider: that of your sales manager. Getting this right is key to your success. Hiring a delegator to manage Renaissance or Enlightened reps will be a disaster. They will quickly learn that they know more than she does and end around her when they need solutions or, even worse, quit in disgust and join up with more established competitors. This class of reps are you crown jewels. The only appropriate custodian for them is someone who understands and appreciates what they bring. I refer, of course, to the hands-on manager:

Hands-On Sales Managers: possess all of the characteristics needed to establish and execute against a sales strategy. However they are also themselves excellent salespeople. They are prepared to pick up the phone and call alongside their reps. They possess expert knowledge about the product, target market and competitors. They collaborate well with marketing, making it easy to align the two functions. Having these strengths means they are always the most logical escalation point for reps. They are the go-to resource for anything and everything (speaking to prospects, closing, training, data-sourcing) because they consistently provide solutions.

One sales manager  I worked with at an IT infrastructure company was very fond of saying “I hate IT but I know sales”. This thinking has no place in a startup. Save that kind of lofty, remote management style for a fully scaled corporate sales organization. If your VP sales can’t get down in the trenches with the team, can’t tell the story as well or better than the best of them, can’t fluently describe a day in the life of the prospect, then you may want to reconsider your choice. Your success depends on it.

I love reading job postings from startups seeking sales execs. There are many reasons for my interest: I’m not very good at writing job specifications so, as a sales manager at a business with no HR function (or funds for recruitment, for that matter), I’m always looking for eye catching and inspirational job ads. I also find that viewing specs helps me to get a feel for who’s hiring in my marketplace. The truth is, I mostly  look at job postings because I find them entertaining. They’re so specific!  There’s almost always a requirement for “ten years of documented over-achievement against plan” and an insistence that “an MBA is preferred”, my personal favorite is “candidate must possess a deep rolodex of  relevant C-level contacts”.

If my decades of sales experience have taught me anything it’s that it’s impossible to exceed plan for ten straight years, (that is, unless one has a sales manager who limited or no experience of setting sales targets). I have also found that sales reps who hold MBA’s are no better than those who don’t (in fact most reps with an MBA are generally more expensive and less willing to prospect, in my experience). But reps with deep C-Suite rolodexes, who are prepared to work at a startup business with few clients and zero brand equity? I think you’re more likely to spot a Yeti on Wall Street than you are to ever successfully recruit such a candidate!

Startup sales managers and founders need to be realistic when it comes to retaining sales people. Keith M Eades, author of “The New Solution Selling”, believes that some 80% of salespeople in the US are journeymen (salespeople who are at or under plan) and only 20% are what he calls “Eagles” (reps who consistently over-perform).  That means that there is a better than 80% chance that the sales exec you hire is going to have a history of mediocre performance (much better, given that the big players tend to jealously hold onto their ‘Eagles’). Let’s face it, the likelihood of an early stage business managing to hire a super-connected Eagle with an MBA is very, very slim. Which begs the question: How can startups de-risk their riskiest endeavor – hiring a sales rep? Below is a list of some approaches that have helped me:

1.) DO NOT MAKE YOUR FIRST SALES HIRE A JOURNEYMAN!

I know what you’re thinking: “But you just told me that there is almost a 100% chance that I’ll hire a journeyman!” Yep, if you adhere to strict hiring criteria like advanced degrees, deep rolodexes and extensive experience of your industry, you’ll likely hire a journeyman. Problem is, you can’t afford to hire one. Journeymen need lots of resources (like tons of qualified sales leads, near constant mentoring and hands-on management) that you will not be able to provide for them.

You’re going to have to think outside of the box if you want to bring a real Eagle on board. There are lots of different ways to achieve this. You might hire and train a brilliant graduate  with zero experience (longer ramp time but fewer bad habits). You can try to retain a salesperson from completely different industry (I once hired a copier rep to sell software who ended up crushing quota for two years straight!). You could even hire a ‘Junior Eagle’, a less experienced rep who will do anything to advance his career, even dial for dollars in a startup. Whichever approach you embrace, never settle for second best. If you do, you’ll find yourself out in the market looking for a replacement rep before you know it.

2.) Remember that salespeople don’t come from central casting

Forget about what you think a salesperson should look like. Successful salespeople are not all wavy haired, lanterned jawed, ex-athletes in Italian suits. I once knew a sales man with coke bottle glasses and a chronic stammer who consistently made $500k a year! Don’t let your preconceptions cloud your judgement. Keep an open mind and you’ll be rewarded.

3) Motivation is more important that any other criteria

I don’t mean to sound crass, but a recently divorced father of three with a gambling problem is always going to be a better sales rep than someone who can live comfortably off his base compensation. Take time to understand what motivates your candidate. Those with no clear impetus to make money must be avoided regardless of pedigree. It is also important to remember that a fiercely competitive nature is just not enough: Wanting to be the best is a nice motivation for taking a job as a sales rep. Having twins who both got into Harvard and now need $50k each per year is even better.

4.) Shy away from reps from large organizations

This is a tough call. Salespeople from established global businesses like IBM, Oracle and Symantec can look good and speak well. They have usually had lots of specialist sales training. They may even have some quality contacts. However, before you hire big enterprise candidates, think carefully about your business environment versus the one they have come from. Did they prospect for business or get handed qualified leads? Did they conduct their own product demonstrations or did they have dedicated sales engineering resource? Did they draft their own proposals or was it done for them by a sales operations team? A lot of Big Enterprise reps just aren’t prepared for the rough and ready nature of a startup.  If you must hire a rep from a large sales organization make sure they have some recent (positive) startup experience.

5.) Speak to non-reference colleagues

You’ve found what appears to be a great sales rep. She presents with tremendous gravitas and enthusiasm. She’s very likable. Her W-2′s look good. Best of all, she appears to have many contacts in the government sector, a potential beachhead for your services. The references she provides vociferously extoll her virtues. Time to make an offer? Not until you have spoken to at least one manager from her last employer who she didn’t give as reference. This can be challenging. You may need to do some digging to find this individual. Regardless, it is critical that you try to speak to someone who worked with her who is not ‘prepped’ for your call. This is the only way to get an honest assessment of the candidate.

It is never easy to find quality sales personnel, whatever size your business is. For founders or sales managers in a startup who have little time to spend recruiting, it can be downright impossible. This said, sticking to some of the simple guidelines I have laid out above should radically improve the chances of getting it right the first time.

Almost every B2B startup I have ever been a part of has been guilty of making the same mistake. The moment the product or service is code-complete the founders go off and hire a salesman. Or, if their revenue objectives are really ambitious, they hire a bunch of salesmen and a sales manager. They may even preemptively hire a couple of presales engineers and some support personnel! After all, the money is going to be flowing in, right? I mean, they’re bringing all of this sales capacity on-stream, right?  Wrong. Salespeople, at the least the sort who are prepared to work for a business with very few customers, are rarely the kind of self-sustaining,  revenue generating ‘capacity’ that management would like them to be. Many founders find this out by hiring and firing a succession of sales reps until someone, usually a VC, intervenes and puts them on the right track. I call this the Sales Trap. I’ve fallen into it myself a few times.

How can SaaS entrepreneurs avoid being ensnared in the Sales Trap? Here are five strategies that have served me and several of my peers well over the years:

1.) Be the first salesperson.

I know. You’re a coder. You don’t like sales. I understand. Salling is hard graft. Especially when it comes to leveraging casual contacts for introductions or picking up the phone and calling strangers. As true as all of this is, you’re going to have to get past your reservations.  There are a ton of highly strategic reasons for founders to get down and dirty on the sales side other than mere revenue generation (establishment of product/market fit, buyer profiling, validating the value proposition, aligning product functionality with market requirements, etc.). Besides, a B2B business is inherently sales-led, if you don’t have some hands-on experience in this area you’ll have a lot of trouble relating to and directing one of your most strategic business functions.So get out there! Have fun with it! (for reading see “The Four Steps to the Epiphany” by Steven Gary Blank)

2.) Build Marketing before Sales.

This is not the most intuitive decision for  entrepreneurs to make. After all, marketing doesn’t directly contribute to revenue and it costs money. It is, however, unavoidable if you wish to reliably and predictably generate sales. Try to expend your resources on low cost tactics for generating awareness and demand like content marketing (blogging, tweeting, whitepapers and webinars), PR, search engine marketing, email marketing or telemarketing. Once you start getting some responses and inbound inquiries, develop a procedure for profiling these to determine which one are the best candidates for your service. BANT (budget, authority, need & timescale) qualification is a simple and useful way to achieve this end. Reliable production of such marketing qualified leads (MQL) is a critical step on the journey to sales success. (see Building a Sales and Marketing Machine on David Skok’s blog)

3.) Measure

You’ve gotten your first deals on your own steam and your marketing efforts are starting to yield MQL’s. It’s a good time to start gathering quantitative data and comparing your findings with your objectives. Avoid ‘analysis paralysis’, you don’t need to measure every aspect of your sales process. At this stage you only require enough information to determine when it’s time to begin scaling your sales operations. This will mean measuring your customer acquisition costs (CAC), your ability to produce MQL’s and convert them into sales (conversion rate) and your own sales performance over the course of a year (productivity per rep). Building a ‘balanced scorecard’ of around five key metrics is critical to the success of your sales efforts. (For reading try “Data Driven Marketing“ by Mark Jeffrey)

4.) Hire when it hurts

Resist the temptation to hire reps until you know you’re at capacity (i.e. you’re producing more MQL’s then your existing reps can handle). Hiring too many reps too quickly can result in a salesforce that is well below plan, which can in turn lead to low morale, reduced productivity and defections to competitors.

5.) Unblock

Create a flow diagram of your sales and marketing process to go along with your balanced scorecard. Review this diagram with your co-founders and managers regularly. Always be vigilant for ‘blockages’ – aspects of your product or process that make it difficult for prospects to procure your services. This unblocking process will soon become the central motivator and ultimate facilitator of succinct, effective sales and marketing meetings.

While there is no guarantee that you’ll avoid being ensnared by the Sales Trap, these strategies should radically improve the odds of building a scalable and effective sales and marketing organization

Tag Cloud

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.